Weird star artifact - bad PA or bad seeing or something else?


Shailesh Trivedi
 

 I imaged the Leo  Triplet using FLI 16803 on a TEC180FL (1134mm FL with reducer-corrector) sitting atop my 1100 with AE. The pixel scale is 1.66 arc-sec/pixel

The PHD2 RMS is bad at 4 to 4.8ish RMS. One image  and PHD2 debug file in the dropbox link below. Is this bad PA, seeing, or something else? 

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/2ow76mjbn52d44qh67rh2/h?dl=0&rlkey=jur5y186awr2g8di1wopwyv4q

Shailesh


 

Hi Shailash, 

Can you please upload your guidelog

thanks

Brian

On Wed, Mar 22, 2023 at 1:31 PM Shailesh Trivedi <shailesh.trivedi@...> wrote:
 I imaged the Leo  Triplet using FLI 16803 on a TEC180FL (1134mm FL with reducer-corrector) sitting atop my 1100 with AE. The pixel scale is 1.66 arc-sec/pixel

The PHD2 RMS is bad at 4 to 4.8ish RMS. One image  and PHD2 debug file in the dropbox link below. Is this bad PA, seeing, or something else? 

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/2ow76mjbn52d44qh67rh2/h?dl=0&rlkey=jur5y186awr2g8di1wopwyv4q

Shailesh




Shailesh Trivedi
 

Brian,

I did upload it, can you not see it?

Shailesh


 

I only see your debug log, I do not see the guidelog



On Wed, Mar 22, 2023 at 2:11 PM Shailesh Trivedi <shailesh.trivedi@...> wrote:
Brian,

I did upload it, can you not see it?

Shailesh




Shailesh Trivedi
 

Got it. Sorry about the confusion. I just uploaded it to the same Dropbox link.

Shailesh


 

Thanks Shailesh

Your guiding is extremely poor, so it's best to head back to the basics and work your way up


For an encoder mount follow these steps: https://youtu.be/wCu8PKjDZ20

Right now you are guiding as though it's a non-encoder mount, which can cause significant degradation to guiding

One thing you should add is after your calibration, perform a guiding assistant run for at least 15 minutes to measure raw mount performance




On Wed, Mar 22, 2023 at 2:57 PM Shailesh Trivedi <shailesh.trivedi@...> wrote:
Got it. Sorry about the confusion. I just uploaded it to the same Dropbox link.

Shailesh




Shailesh Trivedi
 

Reporting back on the PHD2 guiding issue. I moved to version 2.11dev4 and now I get round stars instead of x marks  for stars.

Thank you Brian Valente.

Shailesh


 

👍

Brian

On Mon, Mar 27, 2023 at 3:39 PM Shailesh Trivedi <shailesh.trivedi@...> wrote:
Reporting back on the PHD2 guiding issue. I moved to version 2.11dev4 and now I get round stars instead of x marks  for stars.

Thank you Brian Valente.

Shailesh