Re: Strange Declination Behavior
There is a hot fix on the Bisque website that adds the ReCal function to
the telescope dialog box for A-P scopes. I suggest that everyone using TheSky load up this hot fix! http://www.bisque.com/SC/Downloads/HotFixes/ Mag. 7 skies! Howard Hedlund Astro-Physics, Inc. 815-282-1513 ________________________________ From: ap-gto@... [mailto:ap-gto@...] On Behalf Of Jeff Young Sent: Friday, June 13, 2008 2:57 PM To: ap-gto@... Subject: RE: [ap-gto] Re: Strange Declination Behavior Wade - Not sure (I don't image). I think you may have to do it in PulseGuide (or with the handbox). I'm pretty sure that TheSky doesn't know about Rcal, so I'd guess that MaximDL doesn't either. Cheers, -- Jeff. From: ap-gto@... <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> [mailto:ap-gto@... <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> ] On Behalf Of twade35 Sent: 13 June 2008 20:43 To: ap-gto@... <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> Subject: [ap-gto] Re: Strange Declination Behavior Jeff, I knew I missed something. Is the RCal done in TheSky, MaximDL, or both? Thanks, Wade
|
|
Re: Strange Declination Behavior
Mark Galiyano Jr <mgjr@...>
Wade
Although, rcal is the correct function (as opposed to sync) you don't *need* to do anything. The only problem is you'd need to center your target manually. Any goto operation will cause the mount to flip. I think the meridian delay function can be used to do what you want. This basically tricks the mount into thinking the meridian is shifted. Then you can do your alignment, sync the mount after your first plate solve, use a goto to your target, plate solve and rcal, recenter, and image away. Mark _____ From: ap-gto@... [mailto:ap-gto@...] On Behalf Of Jeff Young Sent: Friday, June 13, 2008 3:23 PM To: ap-gto@... Subject: RE: [ap-gto] Strange Declination Behavior Wade - Your second sync (after crossing the meridian) needs to be a Rcal, not a Sync. Otherwise you're also telling the mount which side of the meridian it's on, which makes it think it's upside down. -- Jeff. From: ap-gto@yahoogroups. <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> com [mailto:ap-gto@yahoogroups. <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> com] On Behalf Of twade35 Sent: 13 June 2008 20:16 To: ap-gto@yahoogroups. <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> com Subject: [ap-gto] Strange Declination Behavior To all, Last night while preparing to image Sh2-27 in H-alpha, I typed in the correct RA and Dec in MaximDL's Telescope dialog and the mount slewed in the wrong direction. It slewed to the south rather than to the north. Here's the steps taken leading up to this strange behavior. First, I polar aligned in the West. After polar aligning, I plate solved on the field of view and sync'd the mount using the solved plate. I then used the mounts keypad to manually slew across the meridian to the chosen target. By doing this, I prevent having to do a meridian flip. I sync'd on Antares. I then typed in the correct RA and Dec and the Dec took off in the wrong direction (i.e. it went south rather than north). I thought the 900GTO mount was able to "sense" crossing the meridian and would compensate for the Declination change. By using the keypad, did I mess up the "sense" of TheSky and/or MaximDL? What is the proper procedure to get things right again? Thanks, Wade
|
|
Re: Strange Declination Behavior
Jeff Young <jey@...>
Wade -
Not sure (I don't image). I think you may have to do it in PulseGuide (or with the handbox). I'm pretty sure that TheSky doesn't know about Rcal, so I'd guess that MaximDL doesn't either. Cheers, -- Jeff. From: ap-gto@... [mailto:ap-gto@...] On Behalf Of twade35 Sent: 13 June 2008 20:43 To: ap-gto@... Subject: [ap-gto] Re: Strange Declination Behavior Jeff, I knew I missed something. Is the RCal done in TheSky, MaximDL, or both? Thanks, Wade
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
Steve Reilly <sreilly@...>
Hey Rick,
I should have qualified it as “my older EdgePort”. I’ve never had any other and this was bought used from a supply liquidator that buys used office/it stuff. I hope that the statement was not seen as a general issue as I have no other data points, except of course, yours now. After I moved it into the warm room, it’s been stable and operating fine for over a year. And I’m assuming it was temperature, it well could have been moisture as it seemed to show up when temperatures were below 45° and often humid. Steve _____ From: ap-gto@... [mailto:ap-gto@...] On Behalf Of Rick Wiggins Sent: Friday, June 13, 2008 2:13 PM To: ap-gto@... Subject: [ap-gto] Re: Keyspan USB Server Hi Steve, I beleive that you have had problems, but wanted to provide another data point. I and many of my friends use the edgeports outside year- round. We have temps getting to 15F (yes it is warmer here than NE) and we typically have high moisture (occassionally ice-fog). I have not heard of any failures. I will provide on tip. I place my edgeport and similar devices near the computers so they experience air that is warmer than ambient. I do it to prevent dewing, but it keeps the temp up also. Thanks, Rick --- In ap-gto@yahoogroups. <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> com, "Steve Reilly" <sreilly@...> wrote: below 45° or so. I moved it into my warm room but still a consideration,especially if using in the field.[mailto:ap-gto@yahoogroups. <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> com] On Behalf Of Howardphysics.com/products/accessories/software/Serial_USB/se> physics.com/products/accessories/software/Serial_USB/seto, but were confident enough to go ahead and start offering it. Our mainadapters if everything is fully loaded. There are potential issues that stemfrom USB, which in turn communicates in a way that is different fromwhispers and then the original message is compared to what the last personheard, and everyone supposedly gets amused by how the message wascorrupted. Yippie gee whiz! Isn't this fun! Now imagine this game in a roomwhat the system I demonstrated at NEAF is doing, and so far, it hasworked remarkably well for us, even on a machine running Vista.going at once, we did not have the remaining three USB ports of the USBserver simultaneously in use at NEAF. We were also using very smartlywritten software - PulseGuide and TheSky - both of which handle theirserial communications in an intelligent way that doesn't overload the COMadditional USB ports occupied with cameras or other devices whilesimultaneously giving the serial ports a workout. I am very confident that the USBThat was its intended purpose, and I'm sure it will handle four USBdevices at once with flying colors. It was not, however, designed to be asuccess using it in that manner by combining the USB server with the USB tothe USB Server as a remote solution. If we did not feel that it couldbe used successfully, we would not be offering it. I did, however,want to be honest about potential limitations and about the "unknowns"that still exist. Between my busy schedule and the never ending rainhere in the Midwest, I also don't know how or when I'll get more testingget them evaluated a bit further: Another USB server that is USB2.0 forof four, and then the Mini-port Replicator that was mentioned by DaleGhent in an earlier set of posts (21986)the Prolific chip sets that tend to be so problem prone. They usechipsets from Texas Instruments that have the added advantage of containingadapters to be fully updated instead of only updated with band-aids to thedrivers on board the computer. Permit me to repeat: Keyspan USB to Serialstraight through serial cables to eliminate the hassle of trying to findthem in the stores. They are 15 feet in length, and really truly areOn Behalf Of Morgan Spangleyou were experimenting with the Keyspan USB server (I think it wastheir product US-4A). Have you got any progress to report? Seemed very
|
|
Re: Strange Declination Behavior
twade35
Jeff,
I knew I missed something. Is the RCal done in TheSky, MaximDL, or both? Thanks, Wade
|
|
Re: Strange Declination Behavior
Jeff Young <jey@...>
Wade -
Your second sync (after crossing the meridian) needs to be a Rcal, not a Sync. Otherwise you're also telling the mount which side of the meridian it's on, which makes it think it's upside down. -- Jeff. From: ap-gto@... [mailto:ap-gto@...] On Behalf Of twade35 Sent: 13 June 2008 20:16 To: ap-gto@... Subject: [ap-gto] Strange Declination Behavior To all, Last night while preparing to image Sh2-27 in H-alpha, I typed in the correct RA and Dec in MaximDL's Telescope dialog and the mount slewed in the wrong direction. It slewed to the south rather than to the north. Here's the steps taken leading up to this strange behavior. First, I polar aligned in the West. After polar aligning, I plate solved on the field of view and sync'd the mount using the solved plate. I then used the mounts keypad to manually slew across the meridian to the chosen target. By doing this, I prevent having to do a meridian flip. I sync'd on Antares. I then typed in the correct RA and Dec and the Dec took off in the wrong direction (i.e. it went south rather than north). I thought the 900GTO mount was able to "sense" crossing the meridian and would compensate for the Declination change. By using the keypad, did I mess up the "sense" of TheSky and/or MaximDL? What is the proper procedure to get things right again? Thanks, Wade
|
|
Strange Declination Behavior
twade35
To all,
Last night while preparing to image Sh2-27 in H-alpha, I typed in the correct RA and Dec in MaximDL's Telescope dialog and the mount slewed in the wrong direction. It slewed to the south rather than to the north. Here's the steps taken leading up to this strange behavior. First, I polar aligned in the West. After polar aligning, I plate solved on the field of view and sync'd the mount using the solved plate. I then used the mounts keypad to manually slew across the meridian to the chosen target. By doing this, I prevent having to do a meridian flip. I sync'd on Antares. I then typed in the correct RA and Dec and the Dec took off in the wrong direction (i.e. it went south rather than north). I thought the 900GTO mount was able to "sense" crossing the meridian and would compensate for the Declination change. By using the keypad, did I mess up the "sense" of TheSky and/or MaximDL? What is the proper procedure to get things right again? Thanks, Wade
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
Wiggins, Rick
Hi Steve,
I beleive that you have had problems, but wanted to provide another data point. I and many of my friends use the edgeports outside year- round. We have temps getting to 15F (yes it is warmer here than NE) and we typically have high moisture (occassionally ice-fog). I have not heard of any failures. I will provide on tip. I place my edgeport and similar devices near the computers so they experience air that is warmer than ambient. I do it to prevent dewing, but it keeps the temp up also. Thanks, Rick --- In ap-gto@..., "Steve Reilly" <sreilly@...> wrote: below 45° or so. I moved it into my warm room but still a consideration,especially if using in the field.Behalf Of Howardphysics.com/products/accessories/software/Serial_USB/se> physics.com/products/accessories/software/Serial_USB/seto, but were confident enough to go ahead and start offering it. Our mainadapters if everything is fully loaded. There are potential issues that stemfrom USB, which in turn communicates in a way that is different fromwhispers and then the original message is compared to what the last personheard, and everyone supposedly gets amused by how the message wascorrupted. Yippie gee whiz! Isn't this fun! Now imagine this game in a roomwhat the system I demonstrated at NEAF is doing, and so far, it hasworked remarkably well for us, even on a machine running Vista.going at once, we did not have the remaining three USB ports of the USBserver simultaneously in use at NEAF. We were also using very smartlywritten software - PulseGuide and TheSky - both of which handle theirserial communications in an intelligent way that doesn't overload the COMadditional USB ports occupied with cameras or other devices whilesimultaneously giving the serial ports a workout. I am very confident that the USBThat was its intended purpose, and I'm sure it will handle four USBdevices at once with flying colors. It was not, however, designed to be asuccess using it in that manner by combining the USB server with the USB tothe USB Server as a remote solution. If we did not feel that it couldbe used successfully, we would not be offering it. I did, however,want to be honest about potential limitations and about the "unknowns"that still exist. Between my busy schedule and the never ending rainhere in the Midwest, I also don't know how or when I'll get more testingget them evaluated a bit further: Another USB server that is USB2.0 forof four, and then the Mini-port Replicator that was mentioned by DaleGhent in an earlier set of posts (21986)the Prolific chip sets that tend to be so problem prone. They usechipsets from Texas Instruments that have the added advantage of containingadapters to be fully updated instead of only updated with band-aids to thedrivers on board the computer. Permit me to repeat: Keyspan USB to Serialstraight through serial cables to eliminate the hassle of trying to findthem in the stores. They are 15 feet in length, and really truly areOn Behalf Of Morgan Spangleyou were experimenting with the Keyspan USB server (I think it wastheir product US-4A). Have you got any progress to report? Seemed very
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
Hi Group,
I'll try to address some of what's been posted in response to my rather long post yesterday. When I spoke with the engineers at Keyspan, they could not give me a definite answer about temperature range. I told them that our equipment was designed to operate at temps down to -40 degrees. Response: "Oh Wow!" The Keyspan units were not specifically designed with such temperatures in mind, but then again, they don't really have components that should be terribly temperature sensitive. I don't believe that any other similar devices are specifically designed for such low temperatures either. The person I talked to thought that keeping things dry (avoiding frost accumulation) would be more important than actual temperature. Mark's suggestion of dew heaters may be a workable solution to extreme cold, as long as the dew heater doesn't introduce any interference as they can with some CCD cameras. For an observatory, one might also build a small insulated "electronics box" with a small internal heat source like a 15 watt incandescent light bulb - red, of course. For that matter, if using the USB Server, run 110 volts inside the box and simply let the server's power transformer provide the heat. As I mentioned, the camera may really benefit from the USB2.0 server that I am currently starting to evaluate. Stay tuned! Mag. 7 skies! Howard Hedlund Astro-Physics, Inc. 815-282-1513 ________________________________ From: ap-gto@... [mailto:ap-gto@...] On Behalf Of Chris Curran Sent: Friday, June 13, 2008 8:20 AM To: ap-gto@... Subject: [ap-gto] Re: Keyspan USB Server I'd be very interested in how well this works with the camera. I've been told numerous times over the years that USB cameras (without internal buffers, i.e. SBIG) will have problems with this type of rigging (USB over Ethernet). Something about delays and reading the ccd and other subjects I don't understand well enough... Please do keep us posted. cheers & beers --- In ap-gto@... <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> , "Morgan Spangle" <msfainc@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
Chris Curran <curran.chris@...>
I'd be very interested in how well this works with the camera. I've
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
been told numerous times over the years that USB cameras (without internal buffers, i.e. SBIG) will have problems with this type of rigging (USB over Ethernet). Something about delays and reading the ccd and other subjects I don't understand well enough... Please do keep us posted. cheers & beers
--- In ap-gto@..., "Morgan Spangle" <msfainc@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
Morgan Spangle <msfainc@...>
Thanks for the update. I have a source at work for one (free) and I
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
will get one and test it out on my setup. I'm also thinking I might try it wireless, with an apple airport express...could be interesting if I can get it to work! Then I can sit upstairs in my office and run the whole deal - it gets chilly in NY in the winter too. I've got the 1200 mount (serial), Robofocus (serial), SBIG camera (USB), so it'll be a nearly full load. I'll keep you posted. Morgan
--- In ap-gto@..., "Howard" <howard@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
Gary Burk
My Keyspan USB-to-4 serial port adaptor has been in my central Ohio
observatory for about 3 years now with no problems, During the winter the temperature gets down near or a bit below 0F, and during the summer as high as near 100F, although that is unusual. Regards, Gary --- In ap-gto@..., "KG KIRKLEY" <kgkirkley@...> wrote: sreilly@... writes: I’m curious as to the warmest/coldest temperatures these unitshave operated. I ask because the old EdgePort seems to have problemsbelow 45° or so. I moved it into my warm room but still a consideration,especially if using in the field.dark sites with no problems.
|
|
Re: Preferred field polar alignment method?
Pierre Henrotay
Rick,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
PAM is very fast and convenient to use, both for measuring the misalignment and for correcting. What I do observe is that: - the results are not exactly repeatable (say you just measure the misalignment and do it twice without changing anything): the error in amplitude is generally consistent, not the error in hour angle - when measuring the misalignment on 2 distinct regions (on the same side of the meridian), the resulting numbers can be significantly different, both in amplitude and in hour angle - I can never reach figures below 0.5 arcmin, and more typically I get 1 arcminute. Only a few iterations are required (2-3), more do not help. PEMPro is also quite convenient to use, but takes (significantly) more time. The results are definitely more consistent and I believe a better accuracy can be obtained: say you do 2 runs without correcting anything, just to measure the misalignment, you get pretty much the same values for each run. But clearly you need to let the software run for about 3-4 minutes at least in each measuring step before the results can be considered to be meaningful. PEMPro reports show that I can be very close to the pole: my best value so far is an (incredible and somewhat doubtful)... 5 arcsec. More typically is 30 arcsec or below. My procedure so far is to use PAM (more exactly first use the polar scope for rough alignment and quick star drift meridian delay, then PAM) and to start the PAM alignment process in the area where I will be imaging next whenever possible. Most pics so far were made at about 2 arcsec/pixel and I am quite happy to image at least 4 minutes with no guiding, just with PEM on (Mach1). My 2 cents, I'd be happy to hear from further experiences. Pierre
--- In ap-gto@..., "Rick Wiggins" <rickwiggins@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
Mark Jenkins
Wrap a couple of dew heaters around it.
Mark On Jun 12, 2008, at 5:42 PM, Steve Reilly wrote: Hello Howard, [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
astronomertoo
Howard,
Very nice writeup, the kind I can learn from. I ordered a few of the new products a few days ago and look forward to using them. Bob Cuberly --- In ap-gto@..., "Howard" <howard@...> wrote:
We have the units available and up on our website.physics.com/products/accessories/software/Serial_USB/se rialusb.htm We have not tested the USB Server as thoroughly as we would liketo, but were confident enough to go ahead and start offering it. Our mainadapters if everything is fully loaded. There are potential issues thatstem from the fact that serial communicates in a way that is differentfrom USB, which in turn communicates in a way that is different froma secret" where a secret message gets passed around the room viawhispers and then the original message is compared to what the last personheard, and everyone supposedly gets amused by how the message wascorrupted. Yippie gee whiz! Isn't this fun! Now imagine this game in a roomwhat the system I demonstrated at NEAF is doing, and so far, it hasworked remarkably well for us, even on a machine running Vista. Although we had all four ports of the USB to 4-port Serial adaptergoing at once, we did not have the remaining three USB ports of the USBserver simultaneously in use at NEAF. We were also using very smartlywritten software - PulseGuide and TheSky - both of which handle their serialadditional USB ports occupied with cameras or other devices whilesimultaneously giving the serial ports a workout. I am very confident that theUSB server will work extremely well to communicate with USB devices.That was its intended purpose, and I'm sure it will handle four USBdevices at once with flying colors. It was not, however, designed to be asuccess using it in that manner by combining the USB server with the USB to the USB Server as a remote solution. If we did not feel that it couldbe used successfully, we would not be offering it. I did, however,want to be honest about potential limitations and about the "unknowns"that still exist. Between my busy schedule and the never ending rainhere in the Midwest, I also don't know how or when I'll get more testingget them evaluated a bit further: Another USB server that is USB2.0 forGhent in an earlier set of posts (21986)use the Prolific chip sets that tend to be so problem prone. They usechipsets from Texas Instruments that have the added advantage of containingadapters to be fully updated instead of only updated with band-aids to thedrivers on board the computer. Permit me to repeat: Keyspan USB to Serialstraight through serial cables to eliminate the hassle of trying to findthem in the stores. They are 15 feet in length, and really truly are Mag. 7 skies! Howard HedlundBehalf Of Morgan Spangle
|
|
jammed threads
Gerald Sargent <sargentg@...>
Re optical paths, the first time I used it was on tight fitting
"T" threads and I have never had it "migrate" to where it was not needed, however only the smallest amount is needed, I use a cotton bud to apply it - with caution, I have used it for tight fitting optic filters and no problems, Gerald.
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
Hello,
We have the units available and up on our website. http://www.astro-physics.com/products/accessories/software/Serial_USB/se rialusb.htm We have not tested the USB Server as thoroughly as we would like to, but were confident enough to go ahead and start offering it. Our main concern arises when using the USB Server with the USB to Serial adapters if everything is fully loaded. There are potential issues that stem from the fact that serial communicates in a way that is different from USB, which in turn communicates in a way that is different from Ethernet. Think of the old party game of "whispers" or "I've got a secret" where a secret message gets passed around the room via whispers and then the original message is compared to what the last person heard, and everyone supposedly gets amused by how the message was corrupted. Yippie gee whiz! Isn't this fun! Now imagine this game in a room where everyone speaks a different language. This, in effect, is what the system I demonstrated at NEAF is doing, and so far, it has worked remarkably well for us, even on a machine running Vista. Although we had all four ports of the USB to 4-port Serial adapter going at once, we did not have the remaining three USB ports of the USB server simultaneously in use at NEAF. We were also using very smartly written software - PulseGuide and TheSky - both of which handle their serial communications in an intelligent way that doesn't overload the COM ports. Finally, I have not tested other serial based software like focusers, rotators or dew heater controllers, nor have I had additional USB ports occupied with cameras or other devices while simultaneously giving the serial ports a workout. I am very confident that the USB server will work extremely well to communicate with USB devices. That was its intended purpose, and I'm sure it will handle four USB devices at once with flying colors. It was not, however, designed to be a bridge from Ethernet to Serial, even though we are having some success using it in that manner by combining the USB server with the USB to serial adapters. The real test will be for people like you to get these products out in the field and get them working under real observatory situations with a variety of equipment. Just a couple more points: 1. I am most certainly NOT trying to dissuade anyone from trying the USB Server as a remote solution. If we did not feel that it could be used successfully, we would not be offering it. I did, however, want to be honest about potential limitations and about the "unknowns" that still exist. Between my busy schedule and the never ending rain here in the Midwest, I also don't know how or when I'll get more testing done, especially real life testing under the stars. 2. We will also be offering two more products from Keyspan when I get them evaluated a bit further: Another USB server that is USB2.0 for higher speed applications like cameras, but has two ports instead of four, and then the Mini-port Replicator that was mentioned by Dale Ghent in an earlier set of posts (21986) 3. Contrary to several earlier posts, the Keyspan units DO NOT use the Prolific chip sets that tend to be so problem prone. They use chipsets from Texas Instruments that have the added advantage of containing re-programmable ROM. This allows the Keyspan USB to Serial adapters to be fully updated instead of only updated with band-aids to the drivers on board the computer. Permit me to repeat: Keyspan USB to Serial Adapters DO NOT use Prolific chip sets! 4. In addition to the Keyspan units, we have started selling straight through serial cables to eliminate the hassle of trying to find them in the stores. They are 15 feet in length, and really truly are straight-through! Mag. 7 skies! Howard Hedlund Astro-Physics, Inc. 815-282-1513 ________________________________ From: ap-gto@... [mailto:ap-gto@...] On Behalf Of Morgan Spangle Sent: Thursday, June 12, 2008 3:29 PM To: ap-gto@... Subject: [ap-gto] Keyspan USB Server Howard, if you're monitoring this group - when I saw you at NEAF you were experimenting with the Keyspan USB server (I think it was their product US-4A). Have you got any progress to report? Seemed very promising for remotely running the mount, camera, etc.. thanks, Morgan Spangle 1200 GTO
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
Kent Kirkley
In a message dated 06/12/08 17:43:22 Central Daylight Time, sreilly@... writes:
I’m curious as to the warmest/coldest temperatures these units have operated. I ask because the old EdgePort seems to have problems below 45° or so. I moved it into my warm room but still a consideration, especially if using in the field. Interesting? I've had my Edgeport repeatedly down to well below freezing out at dark sites with no problems. Kent Kirkley
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
Steve Reilly <sreilly@...>
Hello Howard,
I’m curious as to the warmest/coldest temperatures these units have operated. I ask because the old EdgePort seems to have problems below 45° or so. I moved it into my warm room but still a consideration, especially if using in the field. Thanks, Steve _____ From: ap-gto@... [mailto:ap-gto@...] On Behalf Of Howard Sent: Thursday, June 12, 2008 6:58 PM To: ap-gto@... Subject: RE: [ap-gto] Keyspan USB Server Hello, We have the units available and up on our website. http://www.astro- <http://www.astro-physics.com/products/accessories/software/Serial_USB/se> physics.com/products/accessories/software/Serial_USB/se rialusb.htm We have not tested the USB Server as thoroughly as we would like to, but were confident enough to go ahead and start offering it. Our main concern arises when using the USB Server with the USB to Serial adapters if everything is fully loaded. There are potential issues that stem from the fact that serial communicates in a way that is different from USB, which in turn communicates in a way that is different from Ethernet. Think of the old party game of "whispers" or "I've got a secret" where a secret message gets passed around the room via whispers and then the original message is compared to what the last person heard, and everyone supposedly gets amused by how the message was corrupted. Yippie gee whiz! Isn't this fun! Now imagine this game in a room where everyone speaks a different language. This, in effect, is what the system I demonstrated at NEAF is doing, and so far, it has worked remarkably well for us, even on a machine running Vista. Although we had all four ports of the USB to 4-port Serial adapter going at once, we did not have the remaining three USB ports of the USB server simultaneously in use at NEAF. We were also using very smartly written software - PulseGuide and TheSky - both of which handle their serial communications in an intelligent way that doesn't overload the COM ports. Finally, I have not tested other serial based software like focusers, rotators or dew heater controllers, nor have I had additional USB ports occupied with cameras or other devices while simultaneously giving the serial ports a workout. I am very confident that the USB server will work extremely well to communicate with USB devices. That was its intended purpose, and I'm sure it will handle four USB devices at once with flying colors. It was not, however, designed to be a bridge from Ethernet to Serial, even though we are having some success using it in that manner by combining the USB server with the USB to serial adapters. The real test will be for people like you to get these products out in the field and get them working under real observatory situations with a variety of equipment. Just a couple more points: 1. I am most certainly NOT trying to dissuade anyone from trying the USB Server as a remote solution. If we did not feel that it could be used successfully, we would not be offering it. I did, however, want to be honest about potential limitations and about the "unknowns" that still exist. Between my busy schedule and the never ending rain here in the Midwest, I also don't know how or when I'll get more testing done, especially real life testing under the stars. 2. We will also be offering two more products from Keyspan when I get them evaluated a bit further: Another USB server that is USB2.0 for higher speed applications like cameras, but has two ports instead of four, and then the Mini-port Replicator that was mentioned by Dale Ghent in an earlier set of posts (21986) 3. Contrary to several earlier posts, the Keyspan units DO NOT use the Prolific chip sets that tend to be so problem prone. They use chipsets from Texas Instruments that have the added advantage of containing re-programmable ROM. This allows the Keyspan USB to Serial adapters to be fully updated instead of only updated with band-aids to the drivers on board the computer. Permit me to repeat: Keyspan USB to Serial Adapters DO NOT use Prolific chip sets! 4. In addition to the Keyspan units, we have started selling straight through serial cables to eliminate the hassle of trying to find them in the stores. They are 15 feet in length, and really truly are straight-through! Mag. 7 skies! Howard Hedlund Astro-Physics, Inc. 815-282-1513 ________________________________ From: ap-gto@yahoogroups. <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> com [mailto:ap-gto@yahoogroups. <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> com] On Behalf Of Morgan Spangle Sent: Thursday, June 12, 2008 3:29 PM To: ap-gto@yahoogroups. <mailto:ap-gto%40yahoogroups.com> com Subject: [ap-gto] Keyspan USB Server Howard, if you're monitoring this group - when I saw you at NEAF you were experimenting with the Keyspan USB server (I think it was their product US-4A). Have you got any progress to report? Seemed very promising for remotely running the mount, camera, etc.. thanks, Morgan Spangle 1200 GTO [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
|
|
Re: Keyspan USB Server
observe_m13
--- In ap-gto@..., "Morgan Spangle" <msfainc@...> wrote:
http://www.astro-physics.com/products/accessories/software/Serial_USB/serialusb.htm
|
|