Re: Mach2 - Elongated stars
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Couple of questions:
1 - what's the mount's serial number
2 - which axis is the elongation
3 - which direction was the scope pointing (RA-Dec)
4 - what scope and focal length or what is the arc sec per pixel.
5 - do you have a picture of your setup?
One comment about balance - it should be easy for you to completely balance the scope with the clutches loose. Can you estimate how many lb out of balance your scope is in Dec? Normally i would not think this would have any effect, but doesn't hurt to check this.
From: yanzhe liu <liuyanzhe@...>
Sent: Sun, Mar 7, 2021 12:44 am
Subject: [ap-gto] Mach2 - Elongated stars
Testing new mach2 for a couple of nights. It works great out of the box and I am very pleased.
One issue bothering me is that I got slightly elongated stars across the entire image (15min Ha sub).
The exact same telescope/CCD were used with another mount and stars were round, I am wondering what I should check (I think there was due to some setup issue, but I could not figure it out).
- Used OAG for guiding, so there should not be any flexure.
- CCD orientation was 0/180 degree. The stars were elongated top to bottom.
- I did polar alignment with PHD2 drift align. PA error should be < 5'. The field rotation of each sub is ~0.01 degree, much larger than the other system (but elongated stars do not look like field rotation, they were same across the image)
- Both RA and DEC guiding curves looked smooth, had similar RMS. DEC correction was mainly to one direction.
- DEC balance was slightly off, camera heavy. Is Mach2 DEC sensitive to this? Will the guiding/image be affected?
I dont think any of the above is of particular concern, except DEC balance. Any comment/help is appreciated.